During the past week in London, I've managed to fit in some
unofficial research about childhood around my real work at the Bodleian
Library and the British Library, where I have been reading girls' school
stories. One thing I won't be listing on my university travel diary is a visit to Hamley's, an amazing toy store on Regent St.
I braved four floors of frazzled parents, hyperactive kids, and enthusiastic staff
demonstrating products in a zany fashion. Though the "zaniness" of
the staff interacting with toys seemed confined to the boys' floor, with more
sedate happenings on the girls' floor. Although technically they're not
"boys'" and "girls'" floors since the "gender
apartheid" of such labelling at this iconic store was pointed out last year.
Nevertheless, the "not-just-for-girls" floor was a
pink wonderland of Barbie, fairies and Hello Kitty. Astonishingly, there is even a beauty salon, at which girls can nag their parents into paying for them to have their nails, make-up or hair
done, with glitter an optional extra. The salon is called Tantrum, and the website of the concept store doesn't give any sense
that a boy would want to tangle with glitter tattoos or nail polish (after all, it's "the
ultimate girls' experience):
Shirley Temple cut-out doll, 1935
The current trends in toys make an ideal contrast to the history of toys and
children's play that is recorded in the exhibits at the V & A Museum of Childhood. The Bethnal Green building once housed an odd mixture of items including collections
from the Food and Animal Products displays at the Great Exhibition, as well as
art works intended to bring culture to London's East End. Since 1973, however, all of the V & A's objects
relating to childhood have been held here. With thousands of items dating from the seventeenth century onwards in the collection, only a fraction is able to be displayed. I gravitated toward toys from the nineteenth century and to those of my own childhood in the 1980s, hence the Jem photograph above (though I was more of a Barbie & the Rockers girl, despite it being a blatant copy). All of the periods represented have much to tell us about how childhood, manufacturing and branding have changed, and to reveal the fine strands that connect the toys of the past with those of the present.
Lillie Langtry soap ad
The Shirley Temple cut-out doll from 1935 is a good example of how celebrity crossed over media platforms long before the Olsen twins. Of course, celebrity association with brands began decades before Temple's dimples charmed the world, with the Museum of Brands, Packaging and Advertising showing some of the products endorsed by music hall performer Lillie Langtry from the 1880s. While images of children, such as Millais' Bubbles, were used to sell products such as soap in the Victorian period, Temple is perhaps the first actual child to spawn her own merchandise.
Walking doll c. 1885
It is miraculous that many of the early toys survive at all, let alone with their accompanying packaging and tiny accessories in some instances. The care taken with them indicates the precious nature of children's toys in the 18th and 19th centuries, and differing ideas about their disposable nature today. The skill and patient labour required in the manufacture of many early toys is evident in the walking doll picture here: a mechanical device that made the doll perambulate was concealed beneath her large skirts. The Museum's amazing display of dolls' houses (which were originally the preserve of adults) shows the extent of the painstaking labour devoted to crafting these miniature replicas.
Amy Miles dolls' house 1890
Though the V & A collection includes a royal dolls' house, the one pictured here from 1890 belonged to a girl named Amy Miles, who is believed to have helped in its construction. There are other objects on display that show how children and parents created or crafted their own amusements. I'm surprised my father didn't design his own board game like the very elaborate home-made game created by one family. A faultless girls' embroidery sampler from the nineteenth century shows the crossover of leisure time with the acquisition of practical skills for homemaking.
There were also amazing displays of optical toys, such as panoramas, shadow theatres and lantern slides, many of which promoted Britain's achievements or explained the customs of its colonies. In my next post, I'll show some of these toys that introduced ideas about the British Empire to children in the 19th and early 20th centuries.
Girl Guide salute, as used when making the promise,
demonstrated by a Canadian Guide and Brownie (1985)
For an
organisation with a small membership, Girl Guides Australia has
attracted local and international media attention in the past week. Though
there are fewer than 30,000 girls and women involved in Guiding in Australia
today, down substantially from a peak of 80,000 and despite a century-long
legacy in which one million Australian women are former Guides, the very idea
of changing a traditional organisation still excites public opinion. This week
the more than century-old Guide promise was revised to remove reference to a
“duty to God” and service to the Queen. The change is clearly intended to stem
the decline in Guiding in Australia. This downward trend is not reflected in
the United Kingdom where there are more than half a million
Guides and one in every three girls of the appropriate age is enrolled in
Brownies. For an organisation teetering on the edge of becoming unviable in its
current form, the change in the Australian Guide promise is a major, and
controversial, step in demonstrating that an organisation built out of British
imperialism is still relevant to 21st century girls in a
postcolonial nation.
Across the past
decade or more, Guiding in Australia had already begun moving away from many of
the traditions that defined it during the mid-20th century. Uniforms
became more casual, with mix-and-match polo shirts and other casual wear.
Overall the new look is less reminiscent of a 1970s QANTAS flight attendent
crossed with a sailor in full regalia in an attempt to lose some of the daggy
connotations associated with being a Guide. In what I thought was a sad moment,
the Brownie section of the movement was merged with Guiding such that there is
no separate uniform for Australian girls in the younger age group (and no
toadstool, Brown Owl, skipping around mirrors, or Woorails, Tintookies or Lullagullis).
Australian
Guiding has been eager to show that it is modern and progressive and a cool
place to be. Witness this television advertisement from three years ago that
was clearly not impressive to the one Guide who chose to comment on it. The
logic of tween and teen years means that anything that girls need be told by
adults is "cool" is, in fact, the farthest thing from being so. Even
I knew that I was flirting with danger as a Brownie in 1988 and did not make
the transition to Guiding when I became too old for my brown dress and yellow
skivvy.
Changes in uniform and name, coupled with attempts to promote Guiding on
television, seemingly did little to attract more girls to an organisation that
was nevertheless making great efforts to provide a relevant and challenging
program for today's girls. Guiding in Australia has an image problem. As in the
UK, the shifting cultural make-up of Australia's population has prompted some
of the changes to Guiding. In 2007, Girl Guides UK introduced a headscarf to
the official uniform to encourage Muslim girls to feel welcome in Guiding. Last
year a Muslim
Guide unit was established in New South Wales in an attempt to draw in
girls from communities who have not traditionally been part of Guiding in
Australia.
Ismaili (a sect of Shia Islam) Girl Guides circa 1920s holding a portrait
of Sir Sultan Mahomed Shah Aga Khan
Nevertheless, any idea that Guiding was or is a solely
Christian organisation is untrue. A substantial number of units, especially in
the United Kingdom, had associations with church groups, but an equally
substantial number were run from neutral community halls or purpose-built huts.
From the beginning, Scout and Guide founder Robert Baden-Powell made it clear
that girls must believe in a higher being in order to join, but the notion of
God did not preclude girls of faiths other than Christianity from becoming
Guides. Indeed, it was the imagined relevance of Guiding and Girl Scouting to
girls from every kind of background that meant that it was adopted in
one-hundred-and-forty-five countries, with Hindu and Muslim nations among those
that formed affiliations with the World Association of Girl Guides and Girl
Scouts not long after its formation. Guiding began in India in 1911, Turkey in
1923, Lybia in 1958 and the United Arab Emirates in 1973, to give just a small
number of examples.
Without denying some of the missionary efforts underlying
the establishment of Guiding in some of these countries, or the historical
separation of Indigenous girls from white girls in some places, Guiding did set
out with goals of being relevant to, and inclusive of, girls of all faiths and
races. Olave Baden-Powell, the World Chief Guide from 1930 until her death in
1977 (and Baden-Powell’s wife), visited over one hundred countries to meet with
Guides, and spent a substantial amount of time in places such as Kenya.
How curious, then, that it is imagined in 2012 that steps
need to be taken to ensure that girls of all faiths and backgrounds are welcome
in Guiding: this idea has been at its core for more than a century. The recent
change is oriented around the “promise”, a brief paragraph that is generally
only spoken once in a Guide’s time in the organisation, unless there is an
extraordinary situation in which the promise is renewed (as at the Guiding
centenary celebrations recently). In this way, it’s reminiscent of a
marriage vow—symbolic, but of little ongoing importance in day-to-day living.
The original British Guide promise read:
“On my honour, I promise that I will do my best-,
To do my duty to God and the King,
To help other people at all times,
To obey the Guide law.”
The promise that I made in Brownies in Australia in the 1980s was very
similar:
“I promise that I will do my best,
To do my duty to God,
To serve the Queen and my country,
To help other people,
and to keep the Brownie Guide law.”
It is also how the Australian Guide promise read (minus the
word “Brownie”) until the following promise was adopted:
“I promise that I will do my best:
To be true to myself and develop my beliefs
To serve my community and Australia
And live by the Guide Law.”
Queen Elizabeth II inspects a Girl Guide
Much of the media response has focused on the removal of God and the Queen from
the promise. Australian Scouts have the option of mentioning the Queen or
leaving her out, but God remains. In the UK, the Guide promise wording is still in the vein
of the original promise, but “to love my God” replaces “do my duty to God”.
This retains the spirit of Baden-Powell’s intent that Guides should believe in
a higher being (though some countries were originally permitted to replace the
term God with an alternative), but that this could accommodate girls of any
religious faith. While Australian Guiding could have similarly changed “duty to
God” to “love my God” to more clearly show the inclusion all kinds of religious
belief, they have instead opted for the vague “develop my beliefs”.
I think this wording indicates that there is no longer a requirement to have any kind
of faith in a god, rather than being an attempt to accommodate girls of all
religious faiths, who have been welcome from the outset. As an atheist, the removal of reference to God does not bother me, but it is intriguing that this change has been presented as
a way of accommodating different religious backgrounds rather than
acknowledgement of Australia’s increasing secularisation, or at least of declining participation in formal religious attendance. There has been
critique of UK and US Guide and Scout organisations for discriminating against
atheists in their membership terms, and this change in Australia has
successfully removed reference to God in a way that seems more accommodating of religious
diversity rather than being irreligious.
Though the removal of reference to the Queen has been of
most interest to monarchist and republicans, the changes to the accompanying Guide
Law are striking for the way they mark of changes in how we perceive childhood. The
original Guide Law was composed in 1910:
"A Guide is loyal and can be trusted.
A Guide is helpful.
A Guide is polite and considerate.
A Guide is friendly and a sister to all Guides.
A Guide is kind to animals and respects all living things.
A Guide is obedient.
A Guide has courage and is cheerful in all difficulties.
A Guide makes good use of her time.
A Guide takes care of her own possessions and those of other people.
A Guide is self-controlled in all she thinks, says and does."
The new Law bears little relationship to the original:
"As a Guide I will strive to:
Respect myself and others
Be considerate, honest and trustworthy
Be friendly to others
Make choices for a better world
Use my time and abilities wisely
Be thoughtful and optimistic
Live with courage and strength."
While it is admirable that girls are encouraged to think
about their potential to change the world, some of the deletions are revealing. To be “cheerful in all difficulties” does suggest a kind of outdated
model of the uncomplaining housewife, yet the notion of staying positive
despite adversity still seems relevant, especially in a world in which
children are increasingly shielded from disappointment and its by-product,
resilience. In the brief discussion of the changes in the Law in the media, the use of the words
“loyal” and “obedient” were seen as especially inappropriate for girls and women. Loyalty is a valuable quality in all humans, and for girls who develop
through contemporary hurdles to coming-of-age, such as cyberbullying, being a trustworthy friend
is surely still important. “Obedience” is much more fraught in that the notion
of women “obeying” their husbands that was embedded in the marriage oath suggested a gendered
obligation to subservience. Nevertheless, it is telling that we no longer
expect children to “obey” or do as they are instructed by parents, teachers, or
community leaders, as in Guiding.
We also lose specific reference to being kind to animals, which is disappointing in an age of factory farming, animal testing, and wholesale destruction
of habitat that is entwined with environmental degradation. What better way to "make choices for a better world" than by "respect[ing] all living things"?
I understand that the girls and leaders involved in Guiding all feel some kind of ownership over the organisation and that agreeing on a new promise and Law must have involved inevitable compromise and concession. The intent of the changes are no doubt worthy, in that they aim to make Australian parents and girls see Guiding as a worthwhile place to socialise with other girls and to develop leadership and practical skills that they might not undertake in school. The removal of God and the Queen from the promise removes much that was symbolic of Guiding throughout its first century. The test will be whether a new model of Guiding, without these traditions, retains sufficient meaning and identity, or whether holding on to these traditional signs, in modified form, and with attempts to modernise, as in the United Kingdom, is a better strategy for the survival of Guiding.
Screenshot of the Girl Museum exhibition home page
Phew! I survived the 'Colonial Girlhood/ Colonial Girls' conference and the Australasian Children's Literature Association for Research (ACLAR) conference in Canberra last week. It was a bustling two weeks and was exciting to meet so many historians and literary scholars working on girlhood in the nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries. We had not one, but two papers on Girl Guiding! Not one, but two, papers on Irish girls' literature! Regular conferences don't often provide for such girlhood riches.
As part of the conference, Associate Professor Cecily Devereux from the University of Alberta delivered a public lecture, 'Fashioning the Colonial Girl: 'Made in Britain' Femininity in the Imperial Archive'. You can listen to the lecture recording and view the slides here. (It's also not every day that a conference keynote speaker discusses Bessie Marchant's adventure fiction in detail.) Our other special event was the launch of the online exhibition 'Home and Away: Girls of the British Empire', which was curated by Ashley Remer, Head Girl at the Girl Museum, with a team of helpers, including Bronwyn Lowe (a PhD candidate in History who assisted us with the conference organisation).
I am indebted to Ashley for being so willing to prepare an exhibition that related to our conference theme and was so pleased to see such a beautiful looking virtual exhibition. One idea that resonated throughout the conference was the lack of archival material documenting the experiences of actual colonial girls: their voices and writings are most often missing from what we can reconstruct. Kristine Alexander's paper on Girl Guide photography unveiled the untapped resource of photographs taken by Guides, who were encouraged to document their activities with specially manufactured Kodak cameras. She also showed how Guiding captured Indigenous girls in photographs, often topless, in ways that reinforced the civilising mission that underwrote the British Empire. The Girl Museum also uses photographs or, more specifically, photographic postcards, to create a global picture of colonial girlhood. While the girls have been posed and framed by adult photographers, the collective impact of these images imparts a powerful sense of the lives of girls in a diverse range of colonial sites.
Our conference endeavoured to enable comparison of the differing manifestations of colonialism around the Empire, and so we were pleased to have papers about girls in Australia, Canada, South Africa, Ireland, New Zealand, Malaya and Zimbabwe. 'Home and Away' exhibits postcards of girls from all of these areas (with the exception of Ireland), as well as drawing in regions we were unable to cover, such as the Caribbean and South Pacific.
There are several striking elements that become visible as you travel across the map of the Empire "on which the sun never set" during your virtual tour. The stories of Indigenous girls, whose lives were irrevocably transformed by colonialism, whether in white settler colonies or colonies of occupation, intertwine with those of the British daughters of the families who performed the work of Empire. In the instance of India, for example, a photograph of young girls from Madras in the 1870s (one of whom appears to be wearing wedding jewellery) shares a page with ringlet-haired, British girl Marjory, who poses in front of a distinctly non-European Christmas tree in the Andaman Islands in around 1908. On the exhibition page about Africa, a young Tanzanian woman, Salima, is charged with brushing the hair of "Gwenneth at seven months" as her ayah. Below this image, six-year-old British girl Elspeth Grant (author of Flame Trees of Thika, a bookabout her African childhood) feeds her pet antelope calf, while wearing what looks like a pith helmet, in Kenya.
As the stories that accompany the photographs explain, colonialism brought with it both oppressive changes for native girls and, within these enforced cultural shifts, some opportunities new to girls and women, like formal education. For British girls, colonialism could enable and excuse modes of behaviour that would not have been acceptable "at home", but images such as that of a girl of perhaps no more than three-years-old wearing her father's Canadian mounted police uniform reinforce the limits of the gendered work of Empire.
The reverse of Ah Moy's postcard
When you click on the photographs themselves, the reverse of a postcard is displayed, on which is printed further information about each image, or speculation about its context where no details have survived. The culture of photographing native peoples for circulation via postcards to the metropolis, as well as the photographing of Indigenous servant girls, is explained throughout these descriptions. While a number of these images are disturbing for their framing according to the anthropological theories of the time, the most upsetting image is perhaps that of Ah Moy, an eight-year-old girl who was reportedly the last slave sold in Hong Kong in 1929. For all of the reasons offered for imperial intervention in India because of child brides and condemned practices such as suttee, the continuation of female slavery in Hong Kong throughout British "ownership" from 1842 to 1922- at which point Winston Churchill announced that the practice would be abolished- showed the varying degrees of concern for colonial girls and their use as justifications for expanding British territory ever further across the globe.
London Morning & Fall Dress Lady's Magazine, August 1810
In my second post on beauty in Victorian women's
magazines, I'd like to consider how British women's magazines came to focus on fashion
and appearance such that the beauty advertisements in my earlier post slotted in seamlessly within an already existing genre of women's print culture. The origins of
what we recognise as a women's magazine rest at the end of the eighteenth century,
yet it was in the nineteenth century that magazines moved to a central place in
popular reading. Part of the reason why magazines became so prolific,
profitable and important to advertisers was because publishers began to target women readers as a specific audience.
A small number of titles intended especially for
women were published in the eighteenth century, such as theLady's Magazine or Entertaining Companion for
the Fair Sex, Appropriated Solely to Their Use and Amusement (1770)(from which we
can see a hand-coloured engraved fashion plate here, a feature which the
magazine popularised in England). But most periodicals were directed at the household
generally or were intended for men, such as the The Gentleman's Magazine (1731). Other magazines of the period had
strong affiliations with church groups and were therefore uninterested in
discussing fripperies such as clothing and hairstyles.
Court Dress, Gallery of Fashion, July 1794
In the
1790s, a number of specialised publications devoted to fashion began to appear,
such as the Gallery of Fashion (1794)
and the Magazine of Female Fashions of
London and Paris (1798). These magazines encouraged existing magazines for
the women's market, such as the Lady's
Magazine, to pay greater attention to fashion coverage amid the usual content
of short stories, serial fiction, poetry, essays on modesty, advice for wives
and mothers, recipes, biographies of famous figures and local and international
news reports.
Dress and appearance entered the women's magazine as
"fashion" through the inclusion of reports of what was being worn by
court ladies in London and in Paris. As Margaret Beetham explains in A Magazine of Her Own?, this type of
content "was to become a staple of women's magazines for the next 200
years and has entered deeply into the ideology of gender" (31). From the
nineteenth century, then, women have learned through women's magazines and how
they present and construct ideas about women's dress and appearance how to be
appropriately feminine.
While
women's status was undergoing a seismic shift through higher education and the
opening up of careers outside the home later in the century, many women’s
magazines do not mirror these changes and are devoid of content about
intellectual matters, education or employment. The Young Ladies’ Journal , which was published from 1864 to 1920,
focused on news of Paris fashions, patterns for needlework, recipes, correspondence, household tips,
court gossip, fiction, and sentimental poetry. Like other women's magazines of the
time, Katherine Ledbetter argues that the Young Ladies' Journal “models
feminine beauty in relation to [a woman's] traditional role in domestic ideology as a
potential partner to a young man” (British
Victorian Women's Periodicals 135). A woman's beauty, or her ability to
cultivate her appearance to fit beauty ideals, were an indicator of her ability
to be a successful wife and mother.
Homes Notes, July 1894
One
of the most influential books about beauty was published in 1836
and was entitled Beauty; Illustrated
Chiefly by an Analysis and Classification of Beauty in Women. The author, Alexander
Walker, identified three main kinds of classic beauty in women: the locomotive
type, which was “striking and brilliant”; the Vital or Nutritive type which was
“soft and voluptuous”; and the Thinking Beauty who displayed “intellectuality
and grace”. Walker suggested that the expanded bosom and “general plumpness”
of Nutritive Beauty was more aesthetically pleasing than the other types, but
these features were also symbolic of women's proper mothering role.Ideas
about women's maternal beauty often inspired angelic connotations, as in this
cover from Home Notes
from 1894 that uses the familiar phrase "The Hand that rocks the Cradle Rules
the World" to suggest women's maternal influence on the next generation. (And you can't miss that she's surrounded by nature in the form of flowers and a bird.)
While I am just starting to think about how women's
beauty is understood in the Victorian period, there is no doubt that we have
abandoned the phase of admiration for the "plumpness" of Nutritive
Beauty. Men no longer consider outward signs of a woman's ability to bear and
nurture children, such as wide hips or sufficient body fat, as integral to
sexual allure. Indeed an extremely thin woman with artificial breasts that may
even hinder mothering are what are most often found on the covers of men's
magazines today. Though I've yet to look at men's magazines at all, I'm of the
understanding that women aren't featured on their covers in the nineteenth
century as they are today. How do we move from maternal beauty as an ideal? And
how do images of women end up selling magazines for both men and women? These
are some of the questions I hope to answer with future work on beauty in
Victorian print culture.
Fairy
tales are badly misunderstood. When we talk about 'fairy tale' romances, as Chloe Angyal did in The Age recently, we ignore the darker
and more subversive history of these ubiquitous stories and the essential part
of the women who originally told them. If you only know fairy tales from the
simpering princesses in Disney films, then you're missing out on cross-dressing
swordswomen, defecating girls and sexually active maidens.
While
it is 200 years since the Grimms collected fairy tales as an academic exercise
to preserve the folklore of Germany, the passing of time has made us forget
that it is not the Grimms who invented them. Fairy tales were usually told by
the fireside in the evening as people, mostly women, worked at essential chores
such as spinning. It is no surprise then that the tales the women spun, such as
Rumpelstiltkin, often included the spinning wheel as a symbol of their labour.
These oral tales were not specifically intended for children and early versions
are frequently crude and highly sexual. In one version of 'Little Red Riding
Hood' collected by the Grimms, but later made wholesome when the second edition
of their Children's and Household Tales was
published for a wider audience, the heroine escapes the wolf by telling him she
has to go outside to "make a load". Before the Grimms removed references
to sex, the witch who keeps Rapunzel imprisoned in a tower knows her not-so-innocent
prisoner has been letting down her hair for a man when her clothes become too
tight because she is pregnant.
'Rapunzel', Wanda Gag, 1936
Various
cultures have their own variants of these tales that are perhaps not 'as
old as time' as Disney suggested in their 'Beauty and the Beast', but which
have a far longer history than we afford them. The Chinese equivalent of
Cinderella, Yeh-hsien, dates from AD 850. In place of a fairy godmother, a
ten-foot long fish rewards her with gold, pearls, dresses and food.
These literary fairy tales and many of the oral versions do not
show women as victims and men and heroes as we expect today. Passive and
obedient heroines have been gradually introduced by male collectors and re-tellers
of the tales across the past two-hundred years, especially as they have sought
to socialise children into masculine and feminine roles. The glittery Disney
collection of princesses obscures the way that fairy tales often showed girls
as mentally or physically strong. They also criticised and punished men for
their exploitation of women.
While Little Red Riding Hood can kill the wolf in a pot of boiling sausage
water in one early version, by the time of Perrault's first written adaptation in
1697, she is relegated to his dinner. The Grimms then transformed what was
often a bawdy story to one entirely about female dependence. Their version
introduces the figure of the huntsman who saves Red by cutting the wolf open
with a pair of scissors.
The Grimms also excised all traces of sexuality from their heroines and instead
promoted stifling ideas of feminine innocence and purity. While this is
partially understandable given their intent to revise the tales for children,
at the same time as deleting the sex, they ramped up the gory violence in ways
not present in the oral tales they were supposedly recording. In their second
edition of tales, they decided to punish Cinderella's step-sisters by having
their eyes pecked out by birds.
Paradoxically, if we want our culture to present
girls and women with empowering models of femininity, in the main, the
seventeenth century versions of fairy tales are better candidates than those of
recent times. Some literary writers such as Angela Carter have already
rewritten fairy tales in a way that returns power to their heroines. Yet the
current crop of film and television fairy tale adaptations, such as Mirror, Mirror and Once Upon a Time, have the potential
to overturn the popular trend of passive heroines in fairy tales in the past
two centuries on a wider scale.
If we look to the history of fairy tales, we can see amid the hundreds of variants
of each tale how much they have changed across time and place. The pink
princess culture that absorbs many girls today is something that they have internalised
from more recent conservative, sanitised versions of fairy tales that suggest
that a woman's greatest achievement is to be innocent and beautiful. If we
returned to telling the fairy tales of old, aspiring to be a fairy tale
princess wouldn't necessarily be such a bad thing.
As part of the Glen Eira Storytelling Festival, the Monash University
Fairy Tale Reading Group is hosting a fairy tale salon inspired by those of
17th Century France on 23 June at Monash Caulfield.
I had the pleasure of being invited to speak at The Johnston Collection (which includes the wonderful Fairhall House museum) last week on beauty in Victorian girls' and women's magazines. I chose magazines in particular because the second half of the nineteenth century was a time in which more people became literate, more magazines were able to be published more affordably, and technological improvements meant illustrations and fashion plates became commonplace. Magazines were the dominant media form, especially as books remained relatively expensive. Not only were women specifically targeted as readers in the nineteenth century, but they were also newly imagined as consumers. The arrival of the the department store, a concept borrowed from France, transformed how items for the self and the home were bought, with their extensive ranges of branded goods arranged in lavish displays designed to be browsed. The illustration above of a woman selecting from a choice of hats from Myra's Journal of Dress and Fashion (Sept. 1885) is one of many depictions of women in the act of shopping that showed its new-found importance to femininity.
Most magazines became heavily dependent on advertising. Even quality publications like The Queen (which became Harper's and Queen) placed ads on almost half of its pages by the mid-1880s. While people complain about ads taking up column inches and screen space today, the strong presence of advertising in the print media is not new. For girls' and women's magazines, the ads that were included were often for products that promised to improve the reader's appearance, with corsets, skin creams and hair products featuring regularly.
Cosmetics, however, had a bad name for encouraging artifice and deception. Charlotte Yonge, the editor of the Anglican girls' magazine The Monthly Packet and author of popular books such as The Daisy Chain opposed cosmetics as a form of lie: "All attempts to pretend to beauties that we do not possess are clearly falsehood, and therefore wrong." Young women in particular were warned away from cosmetics because they were considered more vulnerable to potential damage to their "moral character" because of their sexual associations.
Cosmetics were therefore not commonly advertised but products that would purportedly improve the skin by removing freckles, tans, redness and roughness were promoted because they did not transgress beliefs about "natural" beauty being superior than artificial aids. This ad for Beetham's Glycerine and Cucumber from Woman (11 April 1894) promises to give the user soft, smooth and white skin that "blooms". Along with facial creams, hair products also promised natural improvements to a woman's beauty. Koko for the hair, for instance, is described as a "hair food" that promises to do everything from preventing greyness to eradicating dandruff, but it was not only the hair that benefitted from treatment, as the ad suggests that Koko also stimulated the brain. After brushing with Koko readers are directed to look into a mirror to see the increased "brilliancy" in their eyes, which suggests a benefit to health and well-being, not only appearance.
In the lecture I showed a contemporary Maybelline magazine ad featuring the company's familiar slogan "Maybe She's Born With It. Maybe It's Maybelline" to show the continuation of these ideas about natural beauty (or at least cultivating the appearance of natural beauty) in advertising. It's a real conundrum that women are encouraged to desire products that will "improve" their looks, but they ought to be working to make it seem as if they were "born with" their cosmetically enchanced charms. The many contradictions surrounding women's beauty in Victorian magazines seemed to strike the audience at the lecture as none too dissimilar from those we see in the popular media today. And nowhere are these resonances more obvious than in early advertisements for weight loss, such as Trilene tablets, which promised to "cure corpulency permanently". With that degree of effectiveness, how surprising that they're not still in manufacture.
The poster for the Colonial Girlhood/Colonial Girls conference is now finished. Kristine Moruzi and I are very excited to be hosting so many people from around the world whose work we admire in Melbourne in June.
Our keynote speakers are historian Professor Angela Woollacott from the Australian National University and English scholar Associate Professor Cecily Devereux from the University of Alberta, Canada. Professor Devereux's lecture will be a free public lecture on the evening of the 14th of June from 6.00pm in Elisabeth Murdoch, Theatre A, at the University of Melbourne's Parkville campus. The talk is entitled "Fashioning the Colonial Girl: ‘Made in Britain’ Femininity in the Imperial Archive".
Registration is now open for the two conference days. We have a conference site ready with further details about the event and a link to our secure registration site.